Message-match scorecard: does your page continue your ad?

A reader who clicks an ad expects the next page to continue it. Rate ten checks between your ad and your first screen, and get the fixes ranked by what they are worth.

Message-match scorecard

Free · runs in your browser · nothing is uploaded

The interactive tool needs JavaScript. Without it, here is the example the tool opens with: an ad about sore hips and a story page, scored with sample answers. The method below explains every step.

an ad about sore hips and a story page, scored with sample answers
Score73% (32 of 44 weighted points): gaps to close
Fix firstThe first image does not echo the ad’s visual (4 points)
ThenThe promise only partly continues the ad (3 points)
ThenThe awareness level only partly matches (3 points)
Word overlap57%: sore, hips, side, sleepers shared

When a click leads to a page that feels like a different conversation, people leave. The cause is usually not the page or the ad on its own but the gap between them. This scorecard compares the two with ten checks drawn from the message-match checklist and gives each check a weight.

How to use it

  1. Paste the first line of the ad and the headline of the presell page (optional) to see how many key words carry over.
  2. Open the ad and the page side by side, ideally on a phone, and answer each check No, Partly or Yes.
  3. Read the score and the five fixes with the most points to gain.
  4. Copy the report, download it as CSV or print it for the person who owns the page.

The tool opens with sample answers so you can see a finished scorecard. Click Reset answers to start your own.

The ten checks

GroupCheckWeight
WordsThe page headline reuses the ad’s key words3
WordsLanguage, currency and units fit the targeted country1
PromiseThe page promise is the ad promise, one step further3
PromiseAny offer in the ad is identical on the presell and product page3
ReaderThe reader in the ad is the reader of the page2
VisualThe first image echoes the ad’s visual2
VisualThe brand in the ad is the brand on the page1
LevelThe awareness level matches3
LevelThe format is what the ad promised2
SpeedOn a phone, the first screen loads fast and confirms the promise2

Worked example

With the sample answers (a sore-hips ad and a story page), the weighted points are 32 of a possible 44, or 73%. The biggest gap is the first image: the ad shows one scene, the page another, worth 4 points. Two checks are “partly”: the promise and the awareness level, 3 points each. Fix the image first.

Word overlap, from the sample headline pair: the ad’s distinct key words are waking, sore, hips, side, sleepers, check and knees. The page headline shares sore, hips, side and sleepers: 4 of 7, or 57%. “Waking” and “wake” count as different words, which shows the limit of a word check.

Method and limits

  • Points = answer (0, 1 or 2) × weight. Score = points ÷ (2 × the sum of the weights of answered checks).
  • 80% and above reads as a strong match, 55% to 79% as gaps to close, below 55% as a likely mismatch. These bands are a convenience, not a benchmark.
  • The weights reflect how often each break matters in practice. They are a judgement, and you may disagree: the order of the fixes is what to use.
  • Unanswered checks are left out of the score.

To fix the level, pick a better page type with the format picker. For new headlines, use the headline generator.

Frequently asked questions

What is message match?

The page a visitor lands on continues the thing that made them click: the same words, promise, reader, visual, offer and level of awareness. The message match guide explains each of the six.

How is the score calculated?

Each check is answered No, Partly or Yes, worth 0, 1 or 2 points, multiplied by its weight from 1 to 3. The score is your points divided by the maximum possible for the checks you answered.

Does a high score mean the page will convert?

No. It means the thread from ad to page is unbroken. Conversion also depends on the offer, the price and the traffic. A low score is a reliable list of things to fix; a high one is only a good start.

What does the word-overlap box measure?

The share of the ad’s distinct key words that appear in the page headline, after ignoring small filler words. It does not understand meaning, so a headline can match well with different words. Use it as a prompt, not a verdict.

Does it store my ad or my page?

No. Everything stays in your browser and disappears when you close the page.

More free tools

Go further

Guides that use these numbers

All articles

Strategy11 min read

Message match: connect the ad promise to the landing page

Message match keeps the ad promise clear on the page it opens. Compare the claim, item, reader and offer directly. A fast exit may flag a problem, but it does not tell you its cause. Check the received page before you change the message or judge the result.