Presell page format picker: which format should you build first?

Sixteen formats is a lot to choose from. Answer five questions about your reader, your proof and your traffic, and get the three formats most likely to fit, with the reasons.

Presell format picker

Free · runs in your browser · nothing is uploaded

The interactive tool needs JavaScript. Without it, here is the example the tool opens with: problem-aware buyer, real reviews, several products, social traffic, mid-priced. The method below explains every step.

problem-aware buyer, real reviews, several products, social traffic, mid-priced
1Listicle: 6 points (fits problem-aware readers; scannable on a phone feed)
2Quiz funnel: 6 points (a quiz routes people to the right product; keeps thumbs moving)
3Story advertorial: 5 points (fits problem-aware readers best)

The format of a presell page is a bet about the reader: a story for someone who has not named the problem, a comparison for someone who is choosing, an offer page for someone who is ready. The wrong format wastes a good ad. This quiz narrows sixteen formats to three using five facts you already know.

The five questions

  1. What does the person clicking already know? This is the awareness level1 and the strongest signal.
  2. What proof do you really have? Reviews, a founder story, an expert, a visible progression, strong video, or little yet.
  3. What are you selling? One hero product, several products or profiles, a refill, or a bundle.
  4. Where does the traffic come from? A feed, search or YouTube, native placements, or a warm audience.
  5. How much thinking does the purchase need? Little, some, or a lot.

Worked example

A problem-aware buyer, real reviews, several products, feed traffic and a mid-priced item score like this:

FormatPointsWhy
Listicle64 for problem-aware readers (second choice), 2 for scannable on a phone feed
Quiz funnel62 for problem-aware readers (fourth choice), 3 for several products, 1 for feed traffic
Story advertorial5Best fit for problem-aware readers

With only 1 point between the three, the sensible plan is to test the listicle against the advertorial, and add the quiz if the range really needs routing.

How the points work

The awareness answer gives 5, 4, 3, 2 and 1 points down the list of formats recommended for that level, the same order the product uses when it suggests formats. The other four answers add fixed points to the formats they favour: 3 for a strong match (reviews for customer stories, an expert for Q&A, several products for a quiz, a refill for the calculator), 2 for a good match and 1 for a light one. Nothing is hidden: the reasons behind each score are printed under each result.

Limits

  • The rules encode craft knowledge, not measurements. They do not know your market or your creative.
  • A format is a starting point. The page still needs a message that matches the ad: score it with the message-match scorecard.
  • Different answers can produce close scores. Treat a one-point gap as a tie.

Read about each format on the formats page, and see how real pages look in the examples.

Frequently asked questions

How does the quiz choose?

Your answer about awareness ranks formats the way ClickBanger recommends them for each level, from 5 points for the best fit down to 1. Each other answer adds 1 to 3 points to the formats it favours. The rules are listed on the page, and every recommendation shows its reasons.

Is the top result guaranteed to convert best?

No. The points are a planning aid. They tell you where to start, not what will win. Build your top two and test them against each other with the A/B test calculators.

Why do two formats sometimes tie?

When points are equal, formats are listed alphabetically. A tie means both fit; pick the one you have better material for.

What if I have no reviews or expert?

Choose “Little proof yet”. Discovery articles, listicles and quizzes earn trust through the story or the result, so they do not depend on a stack of reviews.

Does the quiz save my answers?

No. It runs in your browser and forgets everything when you close the page.

Sources

  1. Breakthrough Advertising, Eugene M. Schwartz (1966). The five stages of awareness behind the first question

More free tools

Go further

Guides that use these numbers

All articles